The line breaks and the guns go under,
The lords and the lackeys ride the plain;
I draw deep breaths of the dawn and thunder,
And the whole of my heart grows young again.
For our chiefs said ‘Done,’ and I did not deem it;
Our seers said ‘Peace,’ and it was not peace;
Earth will grow worse till men redeem it,
And wars more evil, ere all wars cease.
But the old flags reel and the old drums rattle,
As once in my life they throbbed and reeled;
I have found my youth in the lost battle,
I have found my heart on the battlefield.
For we that fight till the world is free,
We are not easy in victory:
We have known each other too long, my brother,
And fought each other, the world and we.
(from)A Song Of Defeat G. K. Chesterton
Alliance Commander: "Seems odd you'd name your ship after a battle you were on the wrong side of."
Malcom Reynolds: "May have been the losing side. Still not convinced it was the wrong one."
It's been said that History is written by the Winning Side. But the losers have their own history; and when they gather together over a beer to reminice about past regrets, one of them is bound to tell the story of the Lost Cause; the Noble Defeat; that Glorious Quixotic Crusade that was Doomed to Failure, but which, for a while, seemed so close to succeeding. Even now, in retrospect, it seems like it could have succeeded, if only…
The archtypical Lost Cause, and the one identified by that name by the Other Wiki, is the War of Northern Aggression, (known to those damned Yankees as the Civil War), but there have been many, many others throughout history: the Fall of the Alamo, Bonnie Prince Charlie, the Al Gore Election Campaign of 2000, etc. There's something romantic about these ill-fated enterprises, and their tragic outcomes only enhances their mystique.
But sometimes the mystique covers darker elements. Those who romanticize the Confederate Cause like to emphasize the chivalry and honor of Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee, and the the noblity of the men who fought against overwhelming odds to protect their homes and the sacred principles of States Rights; but they downplay the Slavery aspect.
Notable Lost Causes
Game and Story Use
- A PC might have been invovled in such a Lost Cause in his backstory, such as Mal from the TV series Firefly, who was on the losing side of a rebellion.
- The PC's might become invovled with partisans from a Lost Cause, as David Balfour does in the Robert Louis Stevenson novel Kidnapped.
- Or the campaign itself might be set in the middle of such a cause. The PCs are fighting on a side which, historically, is doomed to fail; but feel honor-bound to fight anyway.
- And perhaps they might make a difference, creating an Alternate History in which the Jacobite Cause triumphs after all…